Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups

Hot chocolate cookie cups are hands down one of the cutest holiday treats I’ve made in my kitchen. Picture this: buttery sugar cookie cups filled with rich chocolate pudding, topped with mini marshmallows and a tiny candy cane handle that looks straight out of a winter wonderland. These adorable bites bring all the cozy vibes of hot cocoa season into one perfectly poppable dessert.

I started making these with Isabella, Emma, and Noah a few years back when we were looking for a fun Christmas baking project. The kids went crazy for the candy cane handles (and yes, we may have “tested” a few extra candy canes along the way). Henry loves how these look on our holiday dessert table, and honestly, they’re always the first thing to disappear at parties.

What makes these special is how simple they are to put together. You’re using ready-to-bake cookie dough as your base, which means less mess and more time decorating. Plus, the combination of that crispy cookie shell with creamy pudding and those little marshmallow bits? Trust me, it’s the perfect balance of textures. If you’re looking for more festive treats, you’ll love these Christmas pinwheel cookies too.

Why You’ll Love This Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups Recipe

• Super simple to make Ready-to-bake cookie dough means you skip the mixing and measuring steps entirely
• Kid-friendly project Little hands love pressing the dough into cups and adding the toppings
• Adorable presentation Those candy cane handles make these look bakery-quality without any fancy skills
• No-bake filling The pudding cups eliminate any complicated custard-making steps
• Perfect party size Mini portions mean guests can grab one (or three) without feeling guilty
• Make-ahead friendly Bake the cups in advance and fill them right before serving

Ingredients You’ll Need for Holiday Cookie Cups

• Sugar cookies (ready to bake) I use the refrigerated dough that comes in a package. Look for brands that have individually portioned pieces
• Ready-to-eat pudding cups (4 cups) Chocolate pudding is classic, but you can totally use vanilla or even butterscotch
• Mini marshmallow bits These are NOT regular mini marshmallows. They’re the dehydrated bits you find near the hot chocolate aisle
• Mini candy canes You’ll cut these to create handles and straws for your cups
• White chocolate candy This acts as edible glue for attaching the candy cane handles
• Christmas sprinkles Any festive mix works. I love the ones with red, green, and white

The beauty of this recipe is that everything comes ready to use. No complicated ingredient lists or specialty items you’ll never use again.

How to Make Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups Step by Step

Prep your oven and pan

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F. Grab a mini-muffin pan (the standard size works perfectly here). You don’t need to grease the pan since the cookie dough has enough fat content.

Shape your cookie cups

Take one piece of ready-to-bake cookie dough and place it in the bottom of each mini-muffin cup. Now here’s the important part: use your fingers to gently press the dough up the sides of the pan. You’re basically creating a little bowl shape. Don’t worry if they’re not perfect they’ll look adorable no matter what.

First bake

Pop them in the oven for 10 minutes. Here’s where the magic happens: as soon as you pull them out, take the end of a wooden spoon (or something similar in size) and gently press down in the center while pushing the sides up. This re-forms that cup shape because the dough will have puffed up a bit during baking.

Second bake

Bake for another 2 minutes. This extra time helps the cups hold their shape better once cooled.

Cool and remove

Let the cookie cups cool completely in the pan. Once they’re cool, use the tip of a knife to gently pop them out. They should release fairly easily you might need to give them a gentle twist, but they shouldn’t stick.

Prepare candy cane handles

Using a sharp knife, carefully cut your mini candy canes. You want to cut them so you have the curved section for a “handle” and the straight part for a “straw.” Be careful here candy canes can be a bit brittle.

Attach the handles

Melt your white chocolate according to package directions (I usually do 30-second intervals in the microwave, stirring between each). Dip the end of your curved candy cane piece into the melted white chocolate, then press it onto the side of your cookie cup. If you’re having trouble getting it to stick (this happens sometimes), here’s my trick: hold the handle against the cup and stick the whole thing in your freezer for 30-60 seconds. The chocolate will set quickly, and then you can let it finish drying for another 1-2 minutes in the freezer.

Fill and top

Right before serving (this is crucial timing), spoon chocolate pudding into each cup. Top with mini marshmallow bits, a sprinkle of those festive Christmas sprinkles, and add your candy cane “straw.” Don’t fill these too far in advance or the cookies will get soggy from the pudding.

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips for Cookie Cups

The cookie cups themselves store beautifully. Once they’re completely cooled, you can keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days. Just don’t add the pudding yet.

For the assembled cups, you really want to fill them right before serving. If you fill them too early, the pudding will make the cookies soft and they’ll lose that satisfying crunch. Trust me on this I learned the hard way at a holiday party when I filled them two hours early.

If you have leftover filled cups (which rarely happens in my house), you can refrigerate them for up to 24 hours. They’ll still taste good, but the cookies won’t be as crispy.

The candy cane handles can be attached a day in advance as long as you store the cups in a cool, dry place. Just keep them uncovered so the chocolate doesn’t get condensation on it.

FAQs About Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups

Final Thoughts on These Edible Cookie Cups

These hot chocolate cookie cups have become a holiday tradition in our house. Every December, the kids ask when we’re making them, and honestly, I look forward to it just as much as they do. There’s something about those tiny candy cane handles and the combo of crunchy cookie with creamy pudding that just screams Christmas.

What I love most is how forgiving this recipe is. Your cookies don’t need to be perfectly shaped. Your candy cane handles can be a little crooked (ours usually are). The important part is making something fun with people you love.

These make incredible gifts too. I’ve packaged them in clear boxes tied with ribbon and given them to neighbors, teachers, and friends. They always get rave reviews.

More Holiday Treats You’ll Love

• Best butter cookies recipe Classic sugar cookies that melt in your mouth
• Blueberry cheesecake cookies recipes Fruity and creamy in every bite
• Best chocolate crinkle cookies recipe Festive chocolate cookies with a snowy powdered sugar coating

Happy baking

Print